AI is already being tested in Malaysian courts, but this is why it might not be a good idea yet

In January, it was reported that Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak Tan Sri Abang Iskandar Abang Hashim said that the courts in Sabah and Sarawak implemented Artificial Intelligence (AI) through a pilot project. And as the AI is currently being tested and used in courts, some are concerned that there was “no proper consultation on the technology’s use”, and that it is “not contemplated in the country’s penal code”.

“Our Criminal Procedure Code does not provide for use of AI in the courts … I think it’s unconstitutional,” said lawyer Hamid Ismail.

Hamid said that he was “uneasy” that the technology was being used before lawyers, judges, and the public fully understood it. The artificial intelligence tool, which was being tested as part of a nationwide pilot, was used when a man he defended was sentenced.

The piloted AI software was developed by Sarawak Information Systems—a state government firm. According to authorities, AI-based systems make sentencing “more consistent and can clear case backlogs quickly and cheaply”. It also “helps all parties in legal proceedings to avoid lengthy, expensive and stressful litigation”.

However, critics have warned AI risks bias against minorities and marginalised groups, saying the technology lacks a judge’s ability to weigh up individual circumstances or adapt to changing social mores. For example, there are reported cases of AI favoring men over women or penalising members of ethnic minorities.

This isn’t a new finding—as newly developed AI can often show bias pretty quickly. Like when a low-resolution picture of Barack Obama was uploaded into an AI face depixeliser, and the output is a white man.

“In sentencing, judges don’t just look at the facts of the case—they also consider mitigating factors, and use their discretion. But AI cannot use discretion,” Ismail noted.

To try and stop its AI software from bias sentencing, Sarawak Information Systems said it had removed the “race” variable from the algorithm. It also noted that the company had only used a dataset of five years from 2014-19 to train the algorithm, “which seems somewhat limited in comparison with the extensive databases used in global efforts”. However, there’s no information on whether it had since expanded its database.

An analysis by Khazanah Research Institute showed that court judges followed the AI sentencing recommendation in a third of the cases—all of which involved rape or drug possession under the terms of the two states’ pilot. For the other two thirds, some judges reduced the suggested sentences, while others toughened sentences on the basis that they would not serve as a “strong enough deterrent”.

“Many decisions might properly be handed over to the machines. (But) a judge should not outsource discretion to an opaque algorithm,” said Simon Chesterman, a senior director at AI Singapore.

[ SOURCE, IMAGE SOURCE ]

Recent Posts

Honor X9c 5G Malaysia: More durable than ever before, priced from RM1,499

Honor has officially launched the Honor X9c 5G here in Malaysia. Despite featuring similar internals…

6 hours ago

Xiaomi’s first clamshell foldable smartphone redefines style in a compact yet powerful form

This post is brought to you by Xiaomi. Combining cutting-edge technology with a sleek, foldable…

7 hours ago

GXBank to rollout GX FlexiCredit this month, GX Biz Banking for MSME coming soon

During its GX 2.0 event, GXBank revealed its new digital financial products aimed at helping…

8 hours ago

GX 2.0: GXBank continues to offer unlimited cashback with some tweaks

GXBank turns one and they have revealed its latest features and initiatives for its next…

9 hours ago

MG ZS EV now available for RM99,999: The cheapest electric SUV in Malaysia

You can now get an MG ZS EV for as low as RM99,999, making it…

10 hours ago

Prime Minister’s Department: Over 1,500 cyberattacks launched at ministries’ infrastructure systems

There have been over 1,500 cases of cyberattacks launched against Malaysian ministries' infrastructure systems in…

15 hours ago

This website uses cookies.